PLOS ONE · Research Article · 5 min read

How to prepare a PLOS ONE revision and response to reviewers

Prepare your response to reviewers, marked manuscript, and clean copy, then check that figures and supporting files match the revision.

An academic slides clipped pages into a folder beside two other folders in a campus café.

An invitation to revise a PLOS ONE manuscript starts a new round of review. The editor needs to see how you addressed the decision letter, where the manuscript changed, and what the revised article says when read on its own. Prepare the response and the two manuscript copies together so a late correction in one file carries through to the others.

Turn the decision letter into a revision plan

Read the editor’s letter alongside the reviews. Make a working list with one row for each actionable point, including instructions from the editor. Record who owns the response, what evidence or decision is needed, what manuscript sections may change, and whether a figure or supporting file will need replacement. Keep the original submitted manuscript in a separate folder so you can always identify the version the reviewers saw.

Work out the dependencies before editing. A change to how an outcome is described may affect the abstract, methods, results, a figure caption, and the wording of the response. Assign one person to check all those locations together. When two reviewers raise the same question, solve it once in the manuscript and record both comment numbers in your working list. That gives you a way to respond to each reviewer while keeping the substantive explanation consistent.

Write the response so each change can be found

PLOS ONE asks authors to address the specific points made by reviewers, respond to editor and reviewer comments, and describe the changes made. Upload the resulting document under the journal’s Response to reviewers designation. If you choose to publish the peer review history, PLOS ONE says your response will appear online alongside the final article. PLOS ONE revision instructions

A practical structure is to group responses under the editor and each reviewer, keep the comments in their original order, and put your reply immediately below each point. Name the action you took and give a location the reader can find. A section and paragraph cue can help when the marked and clean files paginate differently. If you cite line numbers, identify the version they refer to and check them again after the final layout changes.

For example, if a reviewer asks when follow-up began, explain the change in concrete terms: “We clarified in Methods, under Follow-up, that the observation period began on the enrollment date. We also aligned the description in the caption to Figure 2.” If you chose a different approach from the one suggested, explain the reason and say what you changed, if anything. Give the editor enough information to judge the decision without having to infer your reasoning from tracked edits.

Make the marked and clean copies from the same revision

PLOS ONE asks for a copy that shows changes since the original submission and recommends Word’s Track Changes feature. In the submission system, assign the marked file the Revised Article with Changes Highlighted designation. Assign the clean revised copy the Manuscript designation. PLOS ONE revision instructions

If your team has been tracking changes in a single document, save a copy for the marked version and derive the clean version from that same file. In the clean copy, accept the intended changes and remove internal review comments. Merely hiding markup in Word changes the view, so reopen the file and inspect its review settings before handing it off. If collaborators revised separate copies, first reconcile the intended wording into one final manuscript. You can then use Word’s comparison feature with the original submitted version to produce a candidate marked copy, which you should inspect for changes that are missing or hard to follow.

Keep the final filenames distinct enough to recognize in an upload picker. Then spot-check changes that are easy to miss in a prose-only review. Look at table values, symbols, captions, citations, and cross-references. In both copies, find at least one location mentioned in each major response. When you discover a late edit, incorporate it into both manuscript copies and update the response if it refers to that passage.

Check the figures and supporting files that carry forward

PLOS ONE says figures and supporting information from the original submission transfer to the revision unless you update or replace them. Review the carried-forward items in the submission system. An unchanged filename can belong to a figure whose content now disagrees with the revised manuscript. PLOS ONE revision instructions

For each changed figure, compare the uploaded image with the revised caption, panel labels, and callouts. If a supporting file was split, combined, or renumbered, update the manuscript references and any mentions in the response. Review the submission guidelines for the journal’s figure, table, and supporting information conventions as you reconcile the package. PLOS ONE submission guidelines

A useful cross-check is to open each replacement from the upload list or assembled preview and compare one distinctive feature with your final file. That might be a corrected axis label, a new panel, or a revised column heading. This catches old files with similar names and confirms that the submission system has the copy you meant to send.

Review the assembled revision before submitting

Have a coauthor who did less of the editing read the response against the decision letter. Ask them to check whether every point has an answer, whether the changes can be found, and whether each explanation agrees with the clean text. Then inspect the assembled submission or available preview. Confirm that the two manuscript files are assigned to the correct designations, that the markup is visible in the marked copy, and that the clean copy reads naturally from start to finish.

Check any case-specific requests in the editor’s letter, including requests that affect only a declaration, a supporting file, or information in the submission form. If the due date is approaching and you need more time, use the extension contact listed in the journal’s revision instructions. PLOS ONE revision instructions

Keep the final response, both manuscript copies, and any replaced files together after submission. If the editor asks a follow-up question, you can reopen the exact version under review and trace the answer to the files you sent.

Sources used for this guide

Journal instructions can change. The journal's official guidance controls, and Articlo rechecks stored profiles on a schedule.

  1. PLOS ONE Submission Guidelines
  2. PLOS ONE Revising Your Manuscript

See how close your manuscript is to submission.

Choose the journal and upload your draft for a free readiness check. You will see what is ready and what still needs attention before you decide whether to purchase formatting.