Sage
Prepare your manuscript for Campbell Systematic Reviews.
Review the checklist, choose your article type, and turn your draft into a cleaner submission package.
Checked 2026-11-18
Article types
Protocols of systematic reviews or evidence and gap maps
Systematic Reviews
Methods Research Paper
Editorial
Commentaries
Readiness requirements
Review the key details below, or download the complete checklist with every stored source-backed requirement.
Abstract length
- The plain language summary (PLS) should convey the same information as the Abstract but in a completely different language and tone.
Reference style
- Articlo formats your supplied references to the journal's stored style and checks that citations match the reference list; source validity is not verified.
- Authors should also make sure that any renumbered tables, figures, or references match text citations and that figure legends correspond with text citations and actual figures.
Show 1 more
- Commentary articles are expected to be succinct, containing no more than three references.
Figure and table rules
- Keep every figure and table numbered, captioned, and cited in the manuscript.
- If figures and tables are to be published with the article, you should include them within the article.
Show 2 more
- The manuscript must be your original work, you must have the rights to the work, and you must have obtained and be able to supply all necessary permissions for the reproduction of any copyright works not owned by you, including figures, illustrations, tables, lengthy quotations, or other material previously published elsewhere.
- If you have additional materials that need to be published, these can be submitted as a supplementary file with additional details, tables, and figures.
Funding statement
- You should list all funding sources in the Acknowledgments section.
Competing interests
- Add or confirm the author-written Conflict of interest statement; Articlo flags it if author input is still needed.
- If the author has no conflict of interest to declare, they must also state this within the commentary.
Show 2 more
- Commentaries: Commentaries need to include a declaration of interest statement which describes any interest or relationship, financial or otherwise, that might be perceived as influencing an author's objectivity that could be considered a potential source of conflict of interest (refer to Campbell's conflict of interest policy ).
- You will, however, need to attach conflict of interest forms collected from each author in your team.
Data availability statement
- Include or confirm the data availability statement required by the journal. Articlo checks this item and flags anything that still needs author input.
Ethics statement
- Add or confirm the author-written Ethics statement; Articlo flags it if author input is still needed.
- The journal requires that you include in the manuscript details of IRB approvals, ethical treatment of human and animal research participants, and gathering of informed consent, as appropriate.
Author contributions
- Include or confirm the author contributions required by the journal. Articlo checks this item and flags anything that still needs author input.
Supplementary files
- Editorial: Include every cited supplementary file and use matching labels in the manuscript.
- Commentaries: Include every cited supplementary file and use matching labels in the manuscript.
Show 4 more
- Systematic Reviews: Include every cited supplementary file and use matching labels in the manuscript.
- Methods Research Paper: Include every cited supplementary file and use matching labels in the manuscript.
- Protocols of systematic reviews or evidence and gap maps: Include every cited supplementary file and use matching labels in the manuscript.
- Embed or attach the author-supplied supplementary material so Articlo can extract and label it for the package.
Title page and author information
- Commentary articles should include the title, names and affiliations of all authors and a corresponding email address.
- Please note that each co-author must log in to the submission system to add their own ORCID ID to their account.
Show 1 more
- Please create an ORCID ID if you do not already have one or visit our ORCID homepage to learn more.
Reporting guidelines
- Proofs must be returned within 48 hours of receipt of the email.
- The proposed title for your systematic review or EGM should clearly state the scope of the review.
Show 19 more
- This scope should be determined in consultation with key stakeholders including intended end users.
- Please note that you will need to submit your TRF as a web form in ScholarOne.
- The TRF web form in ScholarOne has a drop-down list from which you must select an Editorial Group.
- Commentaries: Commentaries must be germane to the review in question and contribute to deepening the reader’s understanding or advance the science of evidence synthesis.
- The author must be willing to make changes to meet the Campbell standards as well as responding to action letters from the Campbell peer review processes.
- The systematic review must not be a duplicate of a version published elsewhere.
- Systematic Reviews: These links should be referenced in your Campbell Systematic Reviews article.
- All listed authors should have contributed to the manuscript substantially and have agreed to the final submitted version.
- Use of software or tools to conduct evidence synthesis.
- Explicit referencing of the software used, including any validation performed and its application, is required.
- Evidence and gap maps (EGMs) should follow the EGM conduct and reporting standards checklists.
- You may be contacted if any updates or final files are required.
- Submit Manuscript opens in a new tab.
- The update must meet current methodological expectations, outlined in the Campbell Standards, regardless of whether the previous review met these standards (e.g., was published prior to these standards being implemented by Campbell).
- If you do not have a ScholarOne account, click on the link ‘Create an Account’ beside the User ID field to get started.
- The views expressed are those of the authors and may not be attributed to Campbell as they do not represent Campbell policy.
- These can be submitted as completed papers and do not need a title registration process.
- The PLS does not need to be provided in the manuscript text or as a separate file.
- Systematic Reviews: Campbell Systematic Reviews is a gold Open Access journal: authors of accepted papers do not pay an Article Publication Charge since publication fees are covered by Campbell Collaboration.
Preprints and prior publication
- Include or confirm the preprints and prior publication required by the journal. Articlo checks this item and flags anything that still needs author input.
Artificial intelligence disclosure
- Therefore — in accordance with COPE’s position statement on AI tools — these tools cannot fulfill the role of, nor be listed as, an author of an article.
- Artificial Intelligence Generated Content (AIGC) tools — such as ChatGPT and others based on large language models (LLMs) — cannot be considered capable of initiating an original piece of research without direction by human authors.
Submission forms and permissions
- Methods Research Paper: Methods research papers should be submitted to the Campbell Methods Coordinating Group using the ScholarOne submission system.
Language and text style
- 50 words and plain language summary (no more than 650 words) should describe the article using non-technical language, making it accessible to a wider network of readers.
- Commentaries: All commentaries must be written in English.
Show 2 more
- It should summarize your scientific study, its results, and their broader relevance without using jargon so that it is understandable by scientists from outside of your discipline, as well as science journalists and science educators.
- When submitting, authors should enter their plain language title and plain language summary into the box provided in the submission system when prompted.
Statistical reporting
- This may not be relevant if authors used a statistical software package, which is described in the main report.
Article type and manuscript length
- A plain language summary (PLS) is an optional addition that can be submitted for any article type that requires an abstract.
Blinded manuscript
- Except where otherwise stated, manuscripts are peer reviewed by at least two anonymous content reviewers, an Information Specialist and a Methods Editor.
Authorship and originality
- They also cannot be accountable for a published work or for research design, which is a generally held requirement of authorship (as discussed in the previous section), nor do they have legal standing or the ability to hold or assign copyright.
Manuscript structure
- If an author has used this kind of tool to develop any portion of a manuscript, its use must be described, transparently and in detail, in the Methods or Acknowledgements section.
What your package checks
Paper: 650 words
Declarations: Conflict of interest, Ethics, Acknowledgements
Source transparency
This preparation guide uses published journal-specific author requirements. Journal instructions can change, so authors should complete a final review before submission.
Open official guideline source