Sage
Prepare your manuscript for ECNU Review of Education.
Review the checklist, choose your article type, and turn your draft into a cleaner submission package.
Checked 2026-11-18
Article types
Research Review
Research Article
Policy Review
ROE Report
Editorial
Response & Commentary
Readiness requirements
Review the key details below, or download the complete checklist with every stored source-backed requirement.
Abstract length
- Provide an author-written abstract of no more than 150 words.
- For clinical trials, include the trial registry name, registry URL, and registration number at the end of the abstract.
Keywords
- Provide 5-5 keywords chosen by the author.
- The total number of keywords may be expanded to a maximum of 10. [[HEADING_5]] Artwork, figures, and other graphics For guidance on the preparation of illustrations, pictures, and graphs in electronic format, please read Sage’s artwork guidelines.
Show 1 more
- Keywords should be as specific as possible to the research topic.
Reference style
- Articlo formats your supplied references in APA style and checks that citations match the reference list; source validity is not verified.
- Cite this data in your research. [[HEADING_5]] Reference style and citations The journal follows the APA reference style.
Show 5 more
- Citations to preprints are otherwise discouraged. [[HEADING_5]] EndNote If you use EndNote to manage references, you can download the APA 7th EndNote output file. [[HEADING_5]] Supplemental material This Journal can host additional materials online (e.g. datasets, podcasts, videos, images etc.) alongside the full text of the article.
- Every in-text citation must have a corresponding citation in the reference list and vice versa.
- Corresponding citations must have identical spelling and year.
- Authors should update any references to preprints when a peer reviewed version is made available, to cite the published research.
- If you have posted your manuscript to a preprint server, you will be asked to supply the DOI (this does not prohibit submission, but no changes should be made to the preprint version while your manuscript is under evaluation in this journal).
Figure and table rules
- Keep every figure and table numbered, captioned, and cited in the manuscript.
- The manuscript must be your original work, you must have the rights to the work, and you must have obtained and be able to supply all necessary permissions for the reproduction of any copyright works not owned by you, including figures, illustrations, tables, lengthy quotations, or other material previously published elsewhere. [[HEADING_4]] Article types The categories of articles that are published in the journal are listed and described below.
Show 3 more
- If this is not applicable to your manuscript, please state ‘Not applicable’ in this section. [[HEADING_5]] Consent for publication Submissions containing any data from an individual person (including individual details, images or videos) must include a statement confirming that informed consent for publication was provided by the participant(s) or a legally authorized representative.
- For that list and more information please refer to our guidelines on submitting supplemental files. [[HEADING_5]] English language editing services Authors seeking assistance with English language editing, translation, or figure and manuscript formatting to fit the journal’s specifications should consider using Sage Author Services.
- All figures must be numbered consecutively in the order in which they appear in the text – they will appear in the published article in the order they are numbered.
Funding statement
- Add or confirm the author-written Funding statement; Articlo flags it if author input is still needed.
- If no conflict exists, your statement should read: ‘The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article’. [[HEADING_5]] Funding statement All articles need to include a funding statement, under a separate heading, even if you did not receive funding.
Competing interests
- Include or confirm the competing interests required by the journal. Articlo checks this item and flags anything that still needs author input.
Data availability statement
- Add or confirm the author-written Data availability statement; Articlo flags it if author input is still needed.
- Include a data availability statement linking to your data.
Ethics statement
- Add or confirm the author-written Ethics statement; Articlo flags it if author input is still needed.
- If ethical approval was not required, you need to explicitly state this.
Show 3 more
- Please do not submit the participant’s actual written informed consent with your article, as this in itself breaches the patient’s confidentiality.
- All papers reporting studies involving human participants, human data or human tissue must state that the relevant Ethics Committee or Institutional Review Board approved the study, or waived the requirement for approval, providing the full name and institution of the review committee in addition to the approval number.
- The Journal requests that you confirm to us, in writing, that you have obtained written informed consent to publish but the written consent itself should be held by the authors/investigators themselves, for example in a patient’s hospital record.
Cover letter
- Include or confirm the cover letter required by the journal. Articlo checks this item and flags anything that still needs author input.
Author contributions
- Add or confirm the author-written Author contributions statement; Articlo flags it if author input is still needed.
- For multi-author articles, authors must declare the basis for author ordering (e.g., alphabetical, contribution-based, random, or other criteria). [[HEADING_5]] Statements and declarations To ensure proper anonymization, please include a section with the heading ‘Statements and Declarations’ on your title page, after the Acknowledgements section [and Author Contributions section if applicable] including each of the sub-headings listed below.
Show 1 more
- Please include the Author Contributions heading within your submission after the Acknowledgements section.
Title page and author information
- Provide the author, affiliation, and correspondence details for the separate title page; Articlo creates the editable companion file.
- For further information including guidance on fair dealing for criticism and review, please see the Frequently Asked Questions page on the Sage Journal Author Gateway. [[HEADING_5]] Title page To ensure fair and anonymous peer review, your manuscript must be fully anonymized.
Show 10 more
- Do not include any author names in the manuscript file name and remove names from headers and footers.
- The Title Page should include: Article title.
- The listed affiliation should be the institution where the research was conducted.
- Title Page with all required identifying information as laid out in Preparing your manuscript for submission (above).
- Any information that compromises the anonymity of the author(s) should be removed or anonymized and included on the Title Page instead.
- You may be required to enter your declaration of conflicting interest as part of the submission process, in addition to listing it on your manuscript and/or title page.
- Proofs will be made available to the corresponding author via our editing portal, Sage Edit, or by email, and should be returned promptly to avoid delaying publication.
- The author information you enter at submission must exactly match what is included on your manuscript and/or title page, including full names, academic affiliations, and corresponding author contact details.
- Please note that each co-author must log in to the submission system to add their own ORCID ID to their account.
- Please create an ORCID ID if you do not already have one or visit our ORCID homepage to learn more.
Reporting guidelines
- There is no charge either for submitting a manuscript to the journal or publishing with the journal. [[HEADING_3]] Preparing your manuscript for submission Your article must be within the scope of the journal and be of sufficient quality.
- For details of what you can do to influence this, visit How to help readers find your article online. [[HEADING_5]] Title Your manuscript’s title should be concise, descriptive, unambiguous, accurate, and reflect the precise contents of the manuscript.
Show 13 more
- Please note that, where an APC is applicable, production work cannot be completed on your manuscript until payment has been received. [[HEADING_4]] Contributor’s Publishing Agreement Before publication we require the author as the rights holder to sign a Journal Contributor’s Publishing Agreement.
- Research Article: Research articles: These should present original, thought-provoking analysis for educational phenomena.
- The review should focus on a specific education policy issued within two years, and include a brief historical background, current development and its future implication.
- Non-essential identifying details should be omitted.
- If it is not possible to share your data, use the statement to confirm why it cannot be shared.
- Manuscripts should only be submitted with the consent of all contributing authors.
- The individual responsible for submitting the manuscript should carefully check that all those whose work contributed to the manuscript are listed as authors.
- Please note that AI chatbots, for example ChatGPT, should not be listed as authors.
- If your manuscript should be considered for fast-track publication, please explain why.
- Two independent reviews are required for a manuscript to reach a Revise or Accept decision.
- If your submission is being made on your behalf by someone who is not listed as an author, for example the third-party who provided writing/editing assistance, you must state this in the Acknowledgements and also in your covering letter.
- Submissions that do not meet this requirement will not be considered.
- To ensure the integrity of the peer review process we assign reviewers and cannot accept author recommendations.
Preprints and prior publication
- Note that you should not post an updated version of your manuscript on a preprint server while it is being peer reviewed.
- If your manuscript is accepted, you must include a link in your preprint to the final version of your published article. [[HEADING_3]] Peer review policy The following summary describes the peer review process for this journal: Identity transparency: Double Anonymized.
Artificial intelligence disclosure
- If AI tools are used in any way, this should be disclosed to the journal.
Manuscript structure
- If a declaration is not applicable to your submission, you must still include the heading and state ‘Not applicable’ underneath.
- Writing assistance and third party submissions: if you have received any writing or editing assistance from a third-party, for example a specialist communications company, this must be clearly stated in the Acknowledgements section and in the covering letter.
Show 1 more
- You do not need to follow a template, but please ensure your heading levels are clear, and the sections clearly defined.
Article type and manuscript length
- ROE Report: For “Voices/ROE Reports”, the “Abstract” section should be replaced by “Takeaway message” (up to 150 words, 3 to 5 points in complete sentences, put as the last part of the main text). [[HEADING_5]] Keywords Please include a minimum of up to 5 keywords, listed after the abstract.
Authorship and originality
- All persons eligible for authorship must be included at the time of submission (please see the authorship section for more information).
- The Acknowledgments section should include all contributors who do not meet the criteria for authorship.
Show 5 more
- All listed authors must meet the criteria for authorship (above).
- All authors must have given consent for the manuscript to be submitted in its current form.
- If this is not applicable to your manuscript, please state ‘Not applicable’ in this section. [[HEADING_5]] Declaration of conflicting interest The journal requires a declaration of conflicting interests from all authors so that a statement can be included in your article.
- Visit Sage Author Services for further information. [[HEADING_3]] Submitting your manuscript As part of the submission process you will need to confirm that this is your original work, that you have the rights in the work, that this is for first publication in this Journal, that it is not being considered for/has not already been published elsewhere, and that you have obtained and can supply all necessary permissions for the reproduction of any copyright works not owned by you.
- The journal may decline to consider reviews that appear to be primarily AI-generated or that do not meet expected scholarly standards. [[HEADING_4]] Plagiarism The journal and Sage take issues of copyright infringement, plagiarism or other breaches of best practice in publication very seriously.
Supplementary material
- Ensure you upload all relevant manuscript files, including any additional supplemental files (including reporting guidelines where relevant). [[HEADING_4]] Authorship Please view our authorship policies, which includes information on criteria for authorship, who should be the corresponding author and more.
- For that list and more information please refer to our guidelines on submitting supplemental files. [[HEADING_4]] Other information required for submission ORCID ID of the submitting author.
Show 1 more
- Your supplemental material must be one of our accepted file types.
What your package checks
Abstract: 150 words
Keywords: 5-5 keywords
References: APA
Title page: separate file
Declarations: Data availability, Funding, Ethics, Author contributions, Acknowledgements
Source transparency
This preparation guide uses published journal-specific author requirements. Journal instructions can change, so authors should complete a final review before submission.
Open official guideline source